Movie Musicals That Got It Right (I Guess...): Chicago
My Across the Universe review should have sent the message that liking a movie and thinking that it works are two different things. While I feel that Across the Universe had significant weaknesses, I have affection for it. By contrast, I think that Chicago (2002) executes very well... but it leaves me cold. It's not that I hate it. Chicago is highly entertaining, filled with energy that rarely flags. But there is nothing for me to hang my hat on: no one to root for and no appealing message. Yet my view is clearly in the minority, as Chicago is both a commercial and critical darling. Commercially, Chicago is second only to Grease at the box office, with more than $170 million. Critically, it boasts a Certified Fresh rating of 87% on Rotten Tomatoes . It's easy to see why audiences would take to it, with its blend of energy and spectacle, but what's more interesting is why critics -- a notoriously difficult bunch -- seem to like it. Energy and spectacle a